top of page

Can PB and J Be Part of a Healthy Diet?

Updated: Apr 24, 2023

PB & J national day| peanut butter and banana toast

Have you ever taken a trip down memory lane with a PB and J sandwich? For many people, a PB and J sandwich is a nostalgic childhood favorite that brings back happy memories. However, with the rise of concerns about sugar and calorie intake in recent years, some may wonder if this classic meal can fit into a healthy diet plan. In this post, we'll examine the nutritional benefits of PB and J sandwiches and provide tips for making them healthy and delicious. Whether you're a fan of crunchy or smooth peanut butter, we'll debate that at the end! Get ready to learn how to upgrade your PB and J game and make it a part of a balanced diet. But first, a little PB and J history! Have you ever wondered how the peanut butter and jelly sandwich became such an American staple?

Where Does PB and J Come From?

Before we dive into the nutritional benefits of PB and J sandwiches, it's worth exploring where this iconic meal comes from. Surprisingly, the origins of peanut butter and jelly sandwiches can be traced back to the early 1880s when Dr. Ambrose Straub, a St. Louis physician, made a peanut paste for his patients with bad teeth or who had difficulty swallowing.

Smooth Peanut butter for PB and J national day

Dr. Harvey Kellogg (yes, the cereal) was the first to manufacture it. Around 1904, it was brought to a fair and was so popular that grocery stores wanted to sell some. In fact, because peanut butter is a shelf-stable ingredient and high in protein, soldiers were often provided with PB and J sandwiches as a nutritious meal option that was convenient to carry during World War II.

Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches were so easy to make quickly, budget-friendly, and convenient to carry around that they became a worldwide dish quickly. Today, PB and J sandwiches continue to be popular for many, but with concerns about sugar and calorie intake, it's important to ensure they are part of a balanced diet. So let's take a closer look at the nutritional value of this beloved meal and how we can make it a healthier option.

The Nutritional Value of PB and J

PB and J sandwiches may seem like a simple meal option, but they pack quite a nutritional punch. Peanut butter is a great source of protein, healthy fats, and fiber, providing sustained energy and keeping you feeling full for longer. Jam or jelly, on the other hand, can be a good source of vitamins and antioxidants, depending on the type and brand.

However, not all PB and J sandwiches are created equal. Some peanut butter and jelly brands can be high in added and modified sugars and preservatives, which can negate some of the nutritional benefits. It's essential to choose the right ingredients.

PB and J national day different recipe| toast PB and banana with cocoa another with dates and PB

To ensure a healthier option, look for all-natural or organic peanut butter and jelly with minimal added sugars and preservatives. Always go with the one with fewer ingredients. Peanut butter should have peanut butter as the first ingredient and not sugar. Instead of going for some brands with sweeteners, try a natural one and add a teaspoon of maple syrup or honey to your sandwich.

You can make it even more nutritious by making minor adjustments to your PB and J sandwich. Whole-grain bread provides more fiber and nutrients than white bread. Baking your own bread with flour like Kamut, Spelt, and almond can bring even more nutrition to your meal. Adding sliced fruit, such as bananas or berries, can boost the sandwich's nutritional value, adding more vitamins and antioxidants.

Another way to make PB and J a healthy option for kids is to be mindful of portion sizes. A whole sandwich may be too much for some children, so consider making half-sandwiches or pairing a smaller PB and J with a side of fresh veggies or a piece of fruit.

Overall, PB and J sandwiches can be a healthy addition to a balanced diet. They can be a nutritious option for children when made with whole-grain bread and all-natural or organic peanut butter and jelly and served in appropriate portions. In the next section, we'll discuss the age-old debate of crunchy versus smooth peanut butter and how each option can impact the nutritional value of your sandwich.

Crunchy vs. Smooth Peanut Butter; Let's debate

The age-old debate of crunchy versus smooth peanut butter is one that many people feel passionately about. While both options are made from the same ingredients, there are some nutritional differences to consider.

Here are some fun debates facts before we explain the differences. In a study, 70% of college students said they preferred smooth peanut butter over crunchy. In the US, 80% of the sold peanut butter is smooth. We can see here that there's a massive preference, but maybe you are one of the few that prefer the other one, and between you and me, we prefer the crunchy one too!

There is a bit more protein and vitamin E in smooth peanut butter. If you choose one, make sure you read the labels because it is usually higher in saturated fats. In contrast, crunchy peanut butter contains one more gram of fiber. As a result, you will feel full for longer, and your digestion will be improved. Compared to its counterpart, it also has a little more folate.

PB and J national day in a healthy lifestyle| cracker alternative and strawberries

Ultimately, the decision between crunchy and smooth comes down to personal preference, as the variations are not high enough to make a difference in your nutrition. Do you like the crunch or prefer a smooth alternative? You might love both, depending on the recipe you use. For example, we love smooth peanut butter in a celery stick. Both options can be part of a healthy diet if chosen wisely. Avoid those with added sugars, and look at how much sodium they contain. Make sure to keep an eye out for saturated fats, especially in the smooth peanut butter.

Now that we've settled the crunchy versus smooth debate let's move on to some tips for making a healthy PB and J sandwich.

Alternative Ideas for PB and J Meals

Despite your efforts, you can't survive solely on peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. Fortunately, there are plenty of ways to incorporate this childhood classic into other meals. Keep things interesting with these alternative ideas:

  1. PB and J Oatmeal: Cook your oatmeal as usual, then stir in a spoonful of peanut butter and a dollop of jelly. Top with fresh berries or sliced bananas for a sweet and satisfying breakfast.

2. PB and J Smoothie: Blend up a frozen banana, a scoop of peanut butter, a handful of spinach, and some almond milk for a nutrient-packed smoothie that tastes just like your favorite sandwich.

3. PB and J Energy Bites: Mix together peanut butter, oats, honey, and dried fruit to create a no-bake snack that's easy to grab on the go. Roll the mixture into balls and store in the fridge for a quick and tasty snack.

4. PB and J Toast: Toast a slice of whole-grain bread, then spread on some peanut butter and top with sliced strawberries and a drizzle of honey. It's like a deconstructed PB and J sandwich, but better. You could also mash some fruits and spread it over the peanut butter.

5. Make peanut butter and jelly more nutritious by adding seeds. There are many seeds that can be used, such as pumpkin seeds, hemp seeds, flax seeds, buckwheat seeds, etc. We also love adding our homemade sprouts

Healthy lifestyle and PB and J toast with banana and nuts

These are only a few ideas, but the possibilities are endless.

With some creativity, you can enjoy the classic combo in a variety of delicious and healthy ways.,

When consumed in moderation with the right ingredients, PB & J sandwiches can indeed fit into a healthy diet. Whether you're a crunchy or smooth peanut butter fan, there are countless ways to make this classic meal more nutritious and delicious. From swapping out white bread for whole grain to trying out different nut butters or fruit spreads, the possibilities are endless. So, the next time you're craving a PB and J, go ahead and indulge guilt-free, just remember to keep it healthy.

Remember those 4 points to help you

PB and J national day and a healthy lifestyle with blueberries
  • Choose a whole grain bread that is high in fiber and low in added sugars. Look for brands that have at least 3 grams of fiber per slice with less than 2 grams of sugar.

  • Choose a natural peanut butter that has only one or two ingredients - peanuts and salt. Avoid brands that contain added sugars or hydrogenated oils. You can also opt for almond or cashew butter for a different twist.

  • Choose a fruit spread that is made with real fruit and has no added sugars. Look for brands that have fruit listed as the first ingredient. You want to avoid those that contain high fructose corn syrup or artificial sweeteners.

  • Try adding some sliced fresh fruit like bananas or strawberries to your sandwich for extra flavor and nutrition.

Making a PB and J national day sandwich with banana| part of a healthy lifestyle


412 views0 comments


bottom of page